The Fact that Walter and Phyllis got away at the end of the
novel, to me at least doesn’t go with what film noir truly is. Their escape
perverts the genre and makes it seem like noir has an ever after ending to it,
not necessarily a happy ever after, but the possibility of it. The ending in
the novel rids the significance of the entire plot of what the movie is truly
about and that is cynicism, betrayal and ultimate doom. Another thing is that when
developing a genre where in fact there is never a happy ending, the author
should have really put some more thought into it, because like I said, I gives
the possibility of at least an ending where the devious ones can live on.
The
film, on the other side played it out the way it should have. Now I am going by
what the noir genre is. The fact that Walter shot the femme fatal and herself
shot Walter makes for better story line along with noir. More cruel things with
the shooting. The film went right along with it. Regardless if Walter survived
the gunshot wound. The authorities were going to send him to the gas chamber. A
perfect way for a person of his stature and the world he is in, to receive his
death penalty. No good things come from this world of noir. And that’s why the
characters who are twisted deserve to be killed or locked up, or have something
bad happened to them. On the basis by which the genre was created for. Which is
deception, erotic and downright cruel behavior.
The
film version defiantly had many attributes to it, lots of word to describe the characters
and how everything played out. One word stood out to me though, as we see in
the film, Walter is in disarray and is having gut wrenching convections about
his dark actions. He goes about his day always having to look over his
shoulder, complete paranoia. The world he has created for himself is nothing
sort of a nightmare. Constantly stressed, horribly tortured by his own way. The
sleep deprivation causes him to lose focus on his plans. Over all he has
created a nightmarish environment, and it’s everywhere he goes.
The
film supports this quality very well because, of the twisted minds that go into
play with the murder. It goes to show that everyone has a price. And a human
life is no obstacle. The nightmare persona is enhanced by these devilish
actions. As the genre portrays, every twisted character “gets it” in the end.
The film between the man and women is always destructive, causing as I said
earlier a nightmarish environment. All in all the nightmarish quality best describes
how the film is, his worst fear brought to reality, a nightmare living in his own
real world. Everything that could be a nightmare is derived from the fact that
he has committed a murder and things don’t go his way. It forces him to lose
his grip on himself, and is ultimately casted to his own reality nightmare.
To start off, I like how you cut down all your ideas into paragraphs. It makes it easy to follow along that way. In general, you did a great job in answering both questions. Though for the first question I had a different opinion on which ending went more with the style of film noir, I agree with you in the way they got what they deserved. Your argument is strong and your ideas are clear.
ReplyDelete